Thumbsy

Guide3 min read

9 YouTube thumbnail ideas that keep working, with examples

Stuck on your next thumbnail? Here are nine thumbnail ideas that show up again and again in videos that beat their channel, each with real examples.

You do not need a new idea for every thumbnail. Most thumbnails that work are one of a small number of formats, used well. These nine come up again and again in the Thumbsy Vault, a library of thumbnails whose videos beat their channel’s usual views. The examples under each one are real.

1. The before and after

Two states of the same thing, side by side. A room, a body, a bank balance, a car. The viewer sees the change and clicks to see how it happened. 9% of the thumbnails in the Vault use it. Hide part of the “after” if you want even more curiosity.

Before and after thumbnails from the Vault.

2. The comparison

Two different things, split down the middle: cheap against expensive, old against new, one product against its rival. Label each side with one word or a price. It works for reviews, tests and “which is better” videos.

Split screen comparisons from the Vault.

3. The arrow or circle

Point at the one detail that matters. An arrow or a circle tells the eye where to go, and makes people ask what is special about that spot. 19% of the Vault’s thumbnails have an arrow. Use one. Three arrows point at nothing.

Thumbnails that use an arrow to direct the eye.

4. The big number

A price, a count, a time, a score. “$1 vs $100,000”, “100 days”, “0 to 1M”. A number is fast to read and sets up a promise the video has to keep. Make the number the largest thing in the frame.

Thumbnails where a number carries the idea.

5. The close-up

Fill the frame with a face or an object. At phone size, a close-up is the only crop where an expression or a texture is still readable. If your current thumbnail feels weak, cropping in is the cheapest fix there is.

Close-up thumbnails from the Vault.

6. The one object on a clean background

No scene and no clutter, just the thing. A phone, a plate of food, a logo. Minimal thumbnails stand out because the thumbnails around them are busy. This is the format for product videos and calm, expert channels.

Minimal thumbnails from the Vault.

7. The thing with no face

Not every thumbnail needs a person. 49% of the thumbnails in the Vault have none. When the subject is a game, a machine, a place or a result, let it take the whole frame. See the numbers in do faces in thumbnails get more views?.

Thumbnails with no person in them.

8. The picture with no words

21% of the Vault’s thumbnails have no text at all. If the picture already raises the question, words only slow it down. Let the title do the talking. This suits travel, food, nature and anything where the image is the reward.

Thumbnails that work without any text.

9. The dark background

A dark, simple background with one bright subject. It looks serious, it makes colours glow, and it stands out on YouTube’s white page. Documentary, finance and tech channels use it constantly.

Dark background thumbnails from the Vault.

How to choose one

Start from your video, not from the list. Ask what the viewer most wants to see: a change (before and after), a verdict (comparison), a detail (arrow), a scale (number) or a thing (close-up or minimal). Then look at which formats are winning in your niche in the thumbnail makers. When you find one you like, you can make your own version of it there. To learn the craft, read how to make a YouTube thumbnail.

Questions, answered

What are good YouTube thumbnail ideas?

Formats that keep working are the before and after, the side by side comparison, the arrow pointing at one detail, the big number, the close-up and the single object on a clean background.

How do I come up with thumbnail ideas?

Look at videos in your niche that got far more views than their channel usually does, and note the format they use. Then apply that format to your own topic.

Do thumbnails need text?

No. 21% of the thumbnails in the Thumbsy Vault have no text. Use words only when they add something the picture and title do not say.

Is it OK to copy a thumbnail idea?

Borrowing a format, like a before and after, is normal and every large channel does it. Copying someone’s actual picture is not. Use the idea and make the image your own.

Keep reading

Put it to work in the challenge thumbnail maker, weight loss thumbnail maker and product review thumbnail maker, or go back to all articles.

Make your next YouTube thumbnail with AI

Part of Thumbsy Pro, $10 a month for about 16 thumbnails.