Thumbsy

Data2 min read

Do faces in YouTube thumbnails get more views?

The usual advice is to always put a face in your thumbnail. We checked thousands of winning thumbnails, niche by niche. The answer depends on what your video is about.

“Put your face on it” is the most repeated thumbnail advice there is. A big face, a big emotion, done. It is also only half true. We counted how many winning thumbnails show a person, and whether those videos did any better.

How many winning thumbnails show a face

Of the 9,782 thumbnails in the Thumbsy Vault, 51% show a person. Every one of those videos beat its channel’s usual views, so roughly half of them did it with no face at all.

Did the ones with a face do better? No. Thumbnails with a person scored 2.5×, and the ones without scored 2.8×. The score is how many times its channel’s usual views a video got.

Faces by niche

The overall number hides the real story. In business, 79% of winning thumbnails show a person. In gaming, 17% do.

NicheShow a personHave textTypical score
Business79%84%2.5×
Finance76%85%2.6×
Lifestyle69%76%3.2×
Self improvement68%86%2.8×
Food67%68%2.3×
Fitness64%83%3.2×
Entertainment64%72%2.4×
Travel61%76%2.6×
Tech57%77%3×
Education40%81%4×
Sports37%70%2.3×
Gaming17%75%2.4×

When a face helps

  • The video is about a person. An opinion, a story, an interview, a transformation. The face is the subject.
  • Viewers already know you. A familiar face tells subscribers “this is from the channel I like” before they read a word.
  • The emotion is the hook. Shock, doubt or delight on a face tells people how the video will feel.
Thumbnails from the Vault where a person carries the idea.

When to leave the face out

  • The subject is a thing. A game, a gadget, a car, a map. Show the thing as large as you can.
  • The result is the hook. A finished build or a before and after says more than a reaction to it.
  • Your face is small in the frame. A face the size of a thumbnail’s corner reads as clutter, not emotion.
Thumbnails from the Vault that beat their channel with no person in them.

If you use a face, do it properly

  • Make it large: the head should fill at least a third of the height.
  • One clear expression. A neutral face adds nothing.
  • Look at the object or the text, so the viewer’s eye follows yours.
  • Light the face brighter than the background and cut it out cleanly.

In Thumbsy you can upload a few photos once to your brand kit, and the thumbnail makers put you in any thumbnail you make. Then you can try the same idea with and without your face and see which one you would click. More ideas in YouTube thumbnail ideas.

Questions, answered

Do YouTube thumbnails with faces get more views?

Not as a rule. In the Thumbsy Vault, 51% of winning thumbnails show a person, and it depends heavily on the niche.

Should I put my face in my thumbnail?

Yes when the video is about you, your opinion or your reaction. No when the subject is a thing, like a game or a product, which should fill the frame instead.

Which niches use faces the most?

Business and finance. In the Vault, 79% of business thumbnails and 76% of finance thumbnails show a person, against 17% in gaming.

What expression works best in a thumbnail?

A clear one that matches the video. Curiosity and surprise are the feelings winning thumbnails go for most.

Keep reading

Put it to work in the business thumbnail maker, gaming thumbnail maker and podcast thumbnail maker, or go back to all articles.

Make your next YouTube thumbnail with AI

Part of Thumbsy Pro, $10 a month for about 16 thumbnails.