Thumbsy

Basics2 min read

What is an outlier score on YouTube?

An outlier score shows how many times its channel’s usual views a video got. Here is how it is worked out, what counts as a good one, and how to use outliers to plan videos.

A video with a million views sounds like a hit. On a channel that always gets five million, it is a flop. On a channel that usually gets 20,000, it is the best thing they ever made. View counts alone tell you very little. An outlier score fixes that.

What an outlier score is

An outlier score is a video’s views divided by what that channel usually gets. A score of 1× is a normal video for that channel. 3× means three times the usual views. 10× means the video did ten times what the channel normally does.

ScoreWhat it means
Under 1×Below the channel’s usual views
1× to 2×A normal video
2× to 5×A clear win: something about it worked
5× to 10×A breakout
Over 10×Rare. The idea reached far beyond the channel’s own audience

Why outliers matter more than view counts

Big channels get big numbers whatever they post. Subscribers show up. An outlier is different: the video went past the usual audience, which means YouTube showed it to new people and they clicked. The topic, the title and the thumbnail did that, not the channel’s size.

That makes outliers the best place to learn from. A 6× video on a small channel teaches you more than a 1× video on a famous one, and its idea is more likely to work for you too.

Outliers from the Thumbsy Vault. The badge on each one is its score.

What a typical outlier looks like

The Thumbsy Vault holds 9,782 thumbnails picked because their videos beat their channel. 8,653 of them have a score, and the typical one is 2.6×. It varies by niche:

NicheTypical score in the Vault
Education4×
Fitness3.2×
Lifestyle3.2×
Tech3×
Self improvement2.8×
Finance2.6×
Travel2.6×
Business2.5×
Gaming2.4×
Entertainment2.4×
Food2.3×
Sports2.3×

How to find outlier videos

  • By hand. Open a channel’s Videos tab, sort by Popular, and compare the top videos with what the channel gets on a normal upload.
  • While you browse. The Thumbsy Chrome extension lets you save any thumbnail you see on YouTube to your own collection, and Thumbsy shows outlier scores on videos.
  • In a library. The Vault is a hand picked collection of outlier thumbnails you can search by topic, colour, layout or feeling.
  • For your niche, right now. Thumbsy’s Trending shows recent videos that are beating their own channel in the niches you follow.

How to use outliers

  • Collect outliers from your niche in one place. Ten is enough to start seeing patterns.
  • Ask what the outlier did that the channel’s normal videos did not. Usually it is the topic or the thumbnail format.
  • Take the idea, not the image. Use the same angle or layout with your own subject.
  • Look outside your niche. A format that broke out in cooking can be new in finance.

When you find a thumbnail you want to learn from, you can make your own version of it in the thumbnail makers. To see what outliers have in common, read what makes a good YouTube thumbnail.

Questions, answered

What is an outlier score on YouTube?

It is how many times a channel’s usual views a video got. A 5× outlier got five times what that channel normally gets.

What is a good outlier score?

Anything above 2× is a clear win. Above 5× is a breakout. The typical thumbnail in the Thumbsy Vault scored 2.6×.

How is an outlier score calculated?

By dividing the video’s views by the channel’s usual views on recent videos. Tools differ in how they work out “usual”, so scores from different tools are not always the same.

Does YouTube show outlier scores?

No. YouTube shows views only. Outlier scores come from tools such as Thumbsy that compare a video with its channel.

Keep reading

Put it to work in the AI thumbnail maker, investing thumbnail maker and science thumbnail maker, or go back to all articles.

Make your next YouTube thumbnail with AI

Part of Thumbsy Pro, $10 a month for about 16 thumbnails.